Go Back
  • For Business
  • |
  • Warnings
  • Data Suite
  • Newsletters
  • Advertising
  • Superior Accuracy™

Columbus, OH

71°F
Location Chevron down
Location News Videos
Use Current Location
Recent

Columbus

Ohio

71°
No results found.
Try searching for a city, zip code or point of interest.
settings
Columbus, OH Weather
Today WinterCast Local {stormName} Tracker Hourly Daily Radar MinuteCast Monthly Air Quality Health & Activities

Around the Globe

Hurricane Tracker

Severe Weather

Radar & Maps

News

News & Features

Astronomy

Business

Climate

Health

Recreation

Sports

Travel

For Business

Warnings

Data Suite

Newsletters

Advertising

Superior Accuracy™

Video

Winter Center

AccuWeather Early Hurricane Center Top Stories Trending Today Astronomy Heat Climate Health Recreation In Memoriam Case Studies Blogs & Webinars

News

The risks of relying on non-meteorologist experts in weather-related legal cases

Your weather-related case could be at risk if you rely on non-meteorologist experts. A recent legal case highlights credibility concerns and the need for meteorological expertise.

By Adrianne Burke, Content Marketing Manager | AccuWeather For Business

Published Aug 30, 2024 10:55 AM EDT | Updated Aug 30, 2024 3:30 PM EDT

Copied

>>Learn more about AccuWeather For Business

Your case could be at risk if you rely on non-meteorologist experts in weather-related legal cases. A recent case highlights the credibility concerns and the need for meteorological expertise.

In a recent legal case, an insurance company was in a dispute over a wind damage claim. This case involves the use of an expert witness whose testimony relied on automated weather data from a vendor. While the court upheld the insured’s claim, there were significant concerns raised about the credibility of the expert’s testimony.1

The case began when an adjuster reported a wind damage claim to the insurance company on behalf of the insured. The insured claimed that the damage occurred on August 1, 2020. The insurance carrier responded by requesting proof of loss, repair estimates, and related documents. After inspecting the property, the insurance company partially denied the claim, citing that the damage did not meet the policy deductible. Unsatisfied with this decision, the insured replaced the roof at their own expense and filed a lawsuit against their insurance carrier.

One of the key points of this case surrounds the testimony of an expert witness retained by the insured. The insurance company had raised concerns about the expert’s qualifications and the reliability of the data on which his testimony was based. Despite these objections, the trial court allowed the expert’s testimony.

>>READ MORE: AccuWeather's forensics: Answering your most frequently asked questions

In this case, the insurance company challenged the expert’s reliance on automated weather data and the lack of support for its credibility. The expert said he “used it all the time,” but it was insufficient to establish its reliability.

The insurance carrier successfully challenged the reliability of the expert witness’s testimony, leading to the court’s decision to reverse the judgment and remand the case for a new trial. This outcome underscores the importance of critically evaluating expert testimony, especially in cases involving automated weather data and non-meteorologist experts.

Legal professionals and insurance carriers should exercise caution when relying on experts lacking the qualifications and ability to provide credible testimony regarding a weather loss. It is essential to thoroughly assess the methodology, data sources, and expertise of expert witnesses in weather-related cases to ensure the integrity of the legal process.

Relying on non-meteorologist experts to testify about automated weather data from vendors in legal cases carries significant risks:

• Lack of Expertise: Non-meteorologist experts may lack the knowledge to interpret complex meteorological data accurately.

• Data Misinterpretation: These experts may misinterpret data without meteorological training, leading to incorrect conclusions.

• Reliability Challenges: Non-experts may struggle to prove how reliable the weather data is, potentially using flawed information.

• Weather Model Understanding: Non-meteorologist experts may not grasp the strengths and limitations of weather models.

• Case Outcomes: Relying on non-experts can lead to unjust legal decisions, impacting both parties involved.

• Legal Costs and Delays: Engaging non-meteorologist experts may lead to prolonged legal proceedings, increased costs, and complexity.

To ensure the fairness and accuracy of weather-related cases, it is crucial to engage qualified meteorologists, such as the experts of AccuWeather's Forensic team, who can navigate meteorological complexities and provide reliable testimony, upholding legal standards and safeguarding all parties’ interests.

 AccuWeather’s Forensic Meteorology offers a team of expert forensic meteorologists who can provide support to different types of cases, including slip-and-fall incidents, automobile accidents, insurance disputes, property damage claims, aviation incidents, personal injury cases, criminal investigations, wrongful death suits, and more. 

Request a Consultation with an AccuWeather Expert to learn more about how AccuWeather's Forensics Experts can help your case.

1 Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company v. Edward Navlen and Saunee Navelen No. 4D2022-1590

Related:

AccuWeather's forensics: Answering your most frequently asked questions
Five steps to selecting a forensic meteorologist
Weather detectives? No. However, AccuWeather forensic meteorologists can help your case
Report a Typo

Weather News

video

Terrifying moment boulder knocks car off road in China

Jun. 4, 2025
video

Storms cause flooding in Kansas

Jun. 4, 2025
Weather Forecasts

Records in jeopardy as first 90-degree readings expected in Northwest

Jun. 4, 2025
video

How do weather balloons improve forecast accuracy?

Jun. 3, 2025
Show more Show less Chevron down

Topics

AccuWeather Early

Hurricane Center

Top Stories

Trending Today

Astronomy

Heat

Climate

Health

Recreation

In Memoriam

Case Studies

Blogs & Webinars

Top Stories

Severe Weather

Severe storms to hammer central US on daily basis through Saturday

6 hours ago

Weather News

Two ‘doomsday fish’ wash ashore this week

9 hours ago

Weather Forecasts

Northeast in the throes of a major warmup, but severe storms lurk

9 hours ago

Severe Weather

Tornado crashes New Mexico wedding photo shoot

1 day ago

Weather News

Wildfire smoke, dust plume from Africa could collide over the South

1 day ago

More Stories

Featured Stories

Weather News

Thai shopkeeper caught off guard as wild elephant visits store

15 hours ago

Weather News

Signs say stinky, scratchy seaweed summer simmers

15 hours ago

Weather News

Two alligators removed from pools in a single day in Florida county

11 hours ago

Weather News

Escaped zebra causes chaos on Tennessee highway, flees into woods

11 hours ago

Weather News

Truck rollover releases 14 million bees onto Washington road

10 hours ago

AccuWeather The risks of relying on non-meteorologist experts in weather-related legal cases
Company
Proven Superior Accuracy About AccuWeather Digital Advertising Careers Press Contact Us
Products & Services
For Business For Partners For Advertising AccuWeather APIs AccuWeather Connect RealFeel® and RealFeel Shade™ Personal Weather Stations
Apps & Downloads
iPhone App Android App See all Apps & Downloads
Subscription Services
AccuWeather Premium AccuWeather Professional
More
AccuWeather Ready Business Health Hurricane Leisure and Recreation Severe Weather Space and Astronomy Sports Travel Weather News Winter Center
Company
Proven Superior Accuracy About AccuWeather Digital Advertising Careers Press Contact Us
Products & Services
For Business For Partners For Advertising AccuWeather APIs AccuWeather Connect RealFeel® and RealFeel Shade™ Personal Weather Stations
Apps & Downloads
iPhone App Android App See all Apps & Downloads
Subscription Services
AccuWeather Premium AccuWeather Professional
More
AccuWeather Ready Business Health Hurricane Leisure and Recreation Severe Weather Space and Astronomy Sports Travel Weather News Winter Center
© 2025 AccuWeather, Inc. "AccuWeather" and sun design are registered trademarks of AccuWeather, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | About Your Privacy Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

Get AccuWeather alerts as they happen with our browser notifications.

Notifications Enabled

Thanks! We'll keep you informed.